Given that Bob is unlikely to be much better than 3 cards over 3 turns, the question I want to ask is whether he deserves to be so ubiquitous. The second upgrade to the class deals enough damage to be worth it, especially alongside Gray Merchant of Asphodel. Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. However, Dark Confidant allows you to obtain cards from your library during your upkeep without actually drawing them which may allow you to bypass this restriction. Archon of Cruelty has been one of the premier reanimation targets in formats like Modern and Cube. Why would you want to limit your card selection if you aren't playing a game that requires those limitations? in paper and on MTGO. This guy is more of gamble unless you have some control over the order of the top cards on your library since youll be losing a ton of life if you draw something with a high mana cost. Providing a decently aggressive body and early card advantage, Dark Confidant was played everywhere. But, yeah, I wonder the same goddam thing every time I see it cast. I know I just bought it from tcgplayer. like i understand pod effects hitting creatures, but it's not like you're going to spend a spell to put bob in you hand so you can spend 2 mana and draw a card next turn. Exquisite Blood and Sanguine Bond are enchantments that go well together. Narwek, Im thinking the same thing as you. Blood Scrivener only makes you lose 1 life, not life equal to the CMC. That extra B mana makes all the difference, in tempo, splashing, impact etc. Las mejores ofertas para Dark Confidant Modern Masters 2015 casi nuevo negro mtico tarjeta rara (363742) abugames estn en eBay Compara precios y caractersticas de productos nuevos y usados Muchos artculos con envo gratis! And besides this has turned into another thread all together. Types: Creature Human Wizard. 11 one-drops, 21 two-drops, 4 three-drops, 3 four-drops, 21 lands. Privacy statement | Let's talk about this. Thanks for all the feedback, guys! Want one more Sanguine Bond in your EDH deck? This site 2023 TappedOut.net, LLC But youll get an extra card and lose some life every turn if your Confidant lives, which is excellent against control and midrange strategies. and Tarmogoyf for the price of a playset of Bobs. Torment of Hailfire is one of the funnier and more impactful cards and win conditions in black EDH decks. Junkaristocratsprice tag 560 maybe a lil more tcg mid price. Not to mention that theres always the second and third Rhino coming. Do I get to choose which one I would prefer to lose my life on? Why are non-Western countries siding with China in the UN. derrico family names and ages; llano uplift location (Im not 100% sure as of this writing and have asked a Magic judge regarding it.). This is a change from previous rules. It does what midrange decks like most: combining removal that drains life in the -X ability and card advantage plus damage in the +1 ability. in that deck because it does require that you blow your Lightning Bolt By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. A 6/5 flying demon is good. A turn by turn analysis follows, so that it can be compared with the theoretical basic curve. It was fine in midrange/Jund () decks for a while. Fifth turn: Another land, two-drop, and finally a three-drop lead us to 22 two-drops/land, and four three-drops, totaling the deck out at 60 cards. Also, I'm not sure that I would want Blood Scrivener Now we have 12 one-drops, 12 two-drops, and 18 lands, for a total of 42 cards. 12 one-drops, 22 two-drops, 4 three-drops, 21 lands. With this hand, the Jund player can use his mana very efficiently, playing Bob on turn 2, drawing a card on turn 3, and then playing Lili that turn. Sell your Dark Confidant (Store Championship Foil) Other Versions. Bitterblossom is a Constructed staple, and a nightmare for decks trying to answer your threats one-for-one. This turn, having drawn two cards we want to play two spells and make our third land drop. Does Exchanging Life Totals Cause Loss of Life? Feeds | When Stronghold Arena enters the battlefield, you gain 3 life for each time it was kicked. sees play and Phyrexian Arena You can't say, they're both two amazing cards that do two different things that are both absolutely crucial. The "Confidant curve" here makes 10 plays over 6 turns. Bile Blight: Disease Targeting a Specific Creature Type. At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. A comparable creature is grob, or mindblade render (less popular). Artists proofs are CCG cards with blank white backs, printed by Wizards of the Coast and issued only to the artists. 2023 Wizards. In a mono-black deck, one that has some higher-CMC cards, I could very easily see Phyrexian Arena @AlexP Good call. Also a lot less players makes for better demand / supply issues. The pros do recognize the power of Arena. After the third card the odds that the game has not ended drop significantly, as it becomes increasingly likely that someone has won the game by that point. s does that deck use? Thanks APPLE01DOJ and sylvannos, I'll see what I can do We can consider this closed, thanks to all who posted. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Then you have to decide which 3-drop to play on turn three, making the unenviable choice of delaying your draw engine and Lili by a turn each, or delaying your draw engine by two turns. . Technically this is a colorless card. You want ninjas, evasive creatures, and cards that cost a lot and can be cast for alternative costs in this kind of deck so that your Yuriko triggers make your opponents lose a bunch of life. Dark Confidant Articles and comments are user-submitted and do not represent official endorsements of this site. It stops storm combos because the opponent dies trying to combo just being there. All rights reserved. Lastly, as dope as that metagame project is, it does come with a disclaimer at the top of the document explaining the reliability of the data. We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. If it's somewhere other than on the stack or if it's fused, a split card's CMC is the sum of each half's CMC. in there, but im kind of thinking..why is he so good? February 6, 8. Dark Confidant in the 2007 Pro Tour Season, Michael Belfatto's MBA 8th Place GP Columbus, Vitor Dama de Rosa's sideboard Worlds Legacy, O'Mahoney-Schwartz maindeck Worlds Legacy. Cruel Ultimatum, once a reason to play control and Grixis (), is still played in casual MTG. Bob is better though cause overall, you lose about the same life. In reading the history of nations, we find that, like individuals, they have their whims and their peculiarities; their seasons of excitement and recklessness, when they care not what they do. You Do Your Best To Hide The Good Parts of Yourself 4. It is important to note that, unlike most cEDH value engines, Bob can only give you one extra card per turn cycle. 2/1 Illustrated by Livia Prima Standard Not Legal Alchemy Not Legal Pioneer Not Legal Explorer Not Legal Modern Legal Brawl Not Legal Legacy Legal Historic Jason Krell February 22, 2023. . 3) Dark Confidant costs 1 less which means he's in play earlier, and gets you at more cards sooner. If you can't afford the card, don't just replace it and expect the deck to work, cause it won't. Draftsim.com is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Fan Content Policy. Enchantments like Warlock Class are both enablers and payoffs for this strategy, having the effect of another enchantment like Wound Reflection. And I can always count on long-time friend and confidant, Bruce Samboy, to look over my shoulder with a lceen, investigator's eye; . Free NL shipping from 50; Ordered today? Sure, you will loose 1 life on land draws, but with Dark Confident, even if you are running cheap cc cards, your still going to be loosing more than 1 on average AND the opponent will see what you are drawing. Terms of Use | As proxy cards are made from actual cheaper bulk common Magic the Gathering cards, they will still have the same back as the normal cards. You cast Mind Rot and knock two cards out of your opponent's hand. Your deck of cards represents all the weapons in your arsenal. If you look like an adept card handler and always win, . For more information, please see our This often translates to life payments. A 2/1 can block Tymna, can attack for Tymna, unlike study, can't be paid for, and most decks just simply don't have the card draw outside of a couple of really good one card engines like remora to draw enough to keep up, so even though it might be the worse draw if you directly compare it to Rhystic study for example, it is there also just purely for redundancy. It takes experience to recognize these things, so don't trash on other people for failing to do so. Angrath, the Flame-Chained makes each opponent discard a card and lose two life, so thats at least scalable in EDH. Once the terror of a Standard format, Siege Rhino defined Standard for all its existence. If Senseis Divining Top revealed that all 3 cards on top of your library have very high mana costs, to avoid losing a ton of life, youre gonna want to have Greed in play which allows you to pay 1 Black mana and 2 life to draw a card. Laurence Guy & J. Peacock - Can't Find Her 2. or the currently $30+ Chord of Calling OT: Comparing Dark Confidant Dark Confidant is a game changer in deck building. in Jund or BUG for example.. it just won't work. I was about to post a forum about this, and noticed that one was already right there. I support WotC's goal of shaping Modern in favor of diversity. How do I align things in the following tabular environment? well Barandis my deck Sheoldred, Whispering One --BLCK-- SCRFC3 fits that bill. lol Is this a real question? 708.4b is rather poorly worded. Now add the playset of Bob and Goyf. See stores for final prices and details. Yes, for the most part. The deck you linked is Extended, which is now gone. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. @bman5604, I never argued that modern wasn't worth it, I was just pointing out the financial hurdles of switching from standard to modern. RACING NOTES. Dark Confidant was reprinted in Modern Masters. Phyrexian Arena is the best option. 4) Dark Confidant costs 1 black, Arena costs 2 black, makeing Confidant easier to splash and easier to ensure you get into play right away. Example: Assault/Batterys mana cost is {3}{R}{G}. All the mana gets used up, the drawing engine starts at its earliest possible moment, and you're free to start casting 4-drops on turn 4. The . Cards from expansions and special sets (like From the Vault, Commander, Duel Decks, etc) are legal in the Legacy format on the date of release of the expansion or . Dark Confidant was, for a long time, the hands-down winner of the most powerful Invitational card. Pedro started playing Magic way back when in Fourth Edition. Today Im taking a look at the best life loss effects in Magic. He dies when you need him to die. You lose life equal to its converted mana cost. I'm starting to hate these budget threads (you can say it isn't a budget thread, but you'd only be lying to yourself). This site 2023 TappedOut.net, LLC 5 out of 5 stars (1,997) Sale Price $4.70 $ 4.70 $ 5.54 Original Price $5.54 . . Discord Server | Dark Confidant: At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. I play B/G/R(Jund colors) in modern, my deck was around $300 to build. It is also worth noting that bob, grob and mindblade are all very easily tutorable due to their colors. Cards Dark Confidant Dark Confidant (Card) $19.99 $17.54 0.2 TIX Average Type Distribution Land ( 30) Planeswalker ( 1) Enchantment ( 7) Artifact ( 12) Sorcery ( 10) Instant ( 15) Creature ( 24) Related Content Sep 3, 2021 Too-Specific Top 10 - Unscheduled Maintenance Double or nothing! $18.27 from $18.27. Dark Confidant - Modern Masters 2015 - NM - Black Mythic Human Wizard - MTG $32.00 $4.99 shipping or Best Offer SPONSORED *FOIL Dark Confidant - Ravnica - Graded BGS 8.5 $120.00 $17.77 shipping 2 watching SPONSORED MTG - Dark Confidant 081 Double Masters Mythic Creature Pack Fresh Near Mint NM $32.30 $5.60 shipping or Best Offer SPONSORED Ravnica: City of Guilds. ), The TCG Player low price on my Melira Pod build is, at this very moment, $898.39. Cardmarket uses cookies and other related tools. To learn more about Dark Confidant, please come to Amazon.com by following the button below! Played. 6. The catch is, if you draw a creature, you must discard it immediately. If you have a deck that can support two black on turn 3, you want Liliana of the Veil Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Scum and Villainy RPG book - Evil Hat - Near Mint - Blades in the Dark spin off at the best online prices at eBay! If you accept all cookies, we will transfer your data to our partners, who will aggregate this data with other website data about you. Do i really want to rape my wallet to get some little guy who's potentially going to damage me considerably? Press J to jump to the feed. Few cards have ended more MTG games than a lethal Tendrils of Agony, which is technically a storm payoff but causes loss of life nonetheless. This means that from about Turn 3 or 4 Night's Whisper will generally be more valuable than a Bob cast on the same turn. You could think of it as no ban modern. depends on what type of deck you want, in jund I end up with and empty hand by turn 4 if I don't have bob in the table, so you need some form of CA. We were all newbs at some point. Tezzeret, Agent of Bolas is a staple in Modern Dimir () artifact decks. It was the word "new" that threw me off. These cookies help us improve our product by analyzing user data and applying personalized functions. want that early card advantage to grind out an opponent with powerful cards.. like Liliana of the Veil It was just a little over a grand. great lakes hockey league salary Top Bar. Privacy statement | Is Loss of Life Considered Noncombat Damage? 1) If Dark Confidant hits a land, you take no damage. Dark Confidant itself isn't a cheap card, either, and there may be a reluctance of letting go of something so expensive that has been a Jund mainstay for years. For the same mana Night's Whisper immediately gives you two cards at the cost of two life. Replacement For Dark Confidant. This is where you can withdraw your consent to the various types of cookies on the website. DMCA requests | Please use this Cookie Management Panel to manage your preferences for . Why are physically impossible and logically impossible concepts considered separate in terms of probability? (I ended up buying them at an LGS because I have a good LGS that I'll support with the few extra dollars I spend over ordering them online. Honestly Bob is a tad overrated. See cards from the most recent sets and discover what players just like you are saying about them. How likely is Yusri to get me an omniscience effect, if I have Krark's Thumb out? Is it suspicious or odd to stand by the gate of a GA airport watching the planes? Articles and comments are user-submitted and do not represent official endorsements of this site. Why? It's funny, because Blood Scrivener Sell one like this; Description. If your intention is card advantage (which it is, when you're playing with Dark Confidant) in no way is Liliana of the Veil better. February 8, 10. At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. Cheaper in the long run. What happens when I remove Mistbind Clique with its champion trigger still on the stack? Reanimate (Commander Collection: Black) | Illustration by Nils Hamm. Importantly for our evaluation, 31.7% of games end on or before Turn 4, and 50.81% of games end on or before Turn 5. The prevalence of cheap removal spells like Lightning Bolt and Fatal Push are very good against him. Designs are printed using one of the highest quality photo printer. As the example shows, the mana cost and converted mana cost of a split card is only the combined mana costs or converted mana costs of its two halves when it's not on the stack or when it's fused. So we should have our third land, second one-drop and second two-drop in these 10 cards. As always, you're down the one card that it cost to cast the spell from your hand. Yes I know it's pricy still but with that said for a competitive tier 1 modern deck you can't skip on quality. Liliana is better, but costs 1 more mana. It's okay, when people first start out, it's hard to recognize the power value of some cards. Its also a source of card advantage and is an awesome planeswalker to play in spider or sacrifice decks. If you cast Assault, the resulting spell is a red spell with a converted mana cost of 1. If you are running a deck that can reliably get combat damage through then I feel that. This card is such a lifedrainer in EDH. Help | Finding the right deck shouldn't be about cost, trust meyou're going to spend a lot more money building three or four ''budget'' decks (which you willbecause you'll keep losing) and finally going to a deck that can actually be a contender. Only by having no hand at all, which red aggro can do well, does Blood Scrivener @ Krayhaft its a preference thing you can make all the arguments and excuses in the world what it boils down to is If you want it or not and what your willing to do to make it happen. Also, just read Barandis's answer about the curve. So if the player had 25 life at the beginning of the turn and ended the turn with 15 life, they effectively lost 10 life. rather than build a brand new deck. Help | does horrible things to the curve. Nimbus Maze: Got Blue but Need White? It used to be a Legacy combo with Griselbrand so you could pay lots of life, draw cards, and recover your life, which continues to fuel the combo. I must admit, I'm picking up a playset of Bobs atm, all new art for my cube and my next deck project which is gonna be jund or bug. It can be very interesting in some EDH decks as well with cheap cards since youll drain the table for a bunch. Dark Confidant {1} {B} Creature Human Wizard At the beginning of your upkeep, reveal the top card of your library and put that card into your hand. This makes it a lot harder to justify playing a second playset of 1BB cards. He is a 2/1 body so if you lose 1 life, he can swing in for 2 to even things up. This site is unaffiliated. Dark Confidant Double Masters Change Version Add to Collection Create Price Alert Dark Confidant Show Card Oracle Text Tabletop Card Kingdom $ 19.99 eBay - Buy It Now $ 18.99 TCGplayer Mid $ 18.68 Magic Online Cardhoarder 0.91 tix MTGOTraders 0.91 tix Show Buylist Prices + Price History Tabletop MTGO 0 0.5 1 1.5 Oct 22 Nov 22 Dec 22 Jan 23 Feb 23 , but I was thinking Blood Scrivener While these draw outlets are slow in the manner that they take a turn to come online and only draw one card per turn, that's still a ton of card advantage. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. But you're building a legacy deck. Pain Seer and Blood Scrivener are creatures with similar effects. The data for that post (which you can look at here) lists the number of times games ended on particular turns. You lose life equal to its mana value. Oh, I'm well aware of its limitations. In every zone except the stack, the characteristics of a split card are those of its two halves combined. It's that important. I wouldn't advise Blood Scrivener Trespassers Curse doesnt look like much, but you get to drain those pesky token players. .). In every zone except the stack, the characteristics of a split card are those of its two halves combined. Card prices and promotional offers represent daily estimates and/or market values provided by our affiliates. . More statistics can be found here http://mtgsalvation.gamepedia.com/Dark_Confidant. Popular posts: Why is Sundering Titan Banned in Commander? Maher won the right to design and be immortalized in his 2004 Magic Invitational submission. Magic:. vs. When Stronghold Arena enters the battlefield, you gain 3 life for each time it was kicked. After Turn 4 he may as well be blank. I am in the same boat, incidentally. But Belakor, the Dark Master can give you a lot more cards, and its always nice when you recast it and fill up your hand as a commander. I run Junk Aristocrats in standard too, and I run Melira Pod in Modern. Life loss is its own sort of thing. Warning issued for necroing a thread. as well.. but if you're on a budget, Blood Scrivener DMCA requests | Either way, you run the risk of then having to make the turn 4 choice between whichever card you held up and something like Olivia Voldaren Blocks Tymna, too. For what Bob does, Liliana does nothing. You tax your opponents spells for the rest of the game on top of being a slow wincon. eBay item number: 234898901862. I was like "wtf this card sucks I lose life for it??" Tappedout has no idea how to play Magic, confirmed. do you any good. What's the difference between a power rail and a signal line? to Liliana of the Veil This skipping years part is the part that is in contention, no one I know has skipped a standard season, much less multiple, to build from scratch t1 modern decks. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. And you do not have spend that much for a budget alternative. Melira Pod is not one of the most expensive decks and doesn't use Bob or Goyf, yet it goes for around twice as much ($1200) at TCP Player mid right now. Dark Confidant: Those Secret Spells Will Cost Ya! or Huntmaster of the Fells Aside from its 3/2 body, its common to deal 7+ damage just from its ETB trigger. Contact | Phyrexian Arena is better than dark tutelage, unless black is just a splash. Even then, that R/B hyper-aggro deck would still want Dark Confidant It might only run a playset each of Marsh Flats Item specifics. The stars gutter and the skies fade and the earth grows weary with years. does not, but the only one you even need is that it costs one less mana. A young outsider of the town, his natural curiosity inspires the Finch children to study and question the world around them in ways that they had not previously considered. The players have influence over what turn the game ends and so an just over half end on turn 5, not accounting for pod composition. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for 1X FOIL Dark Confidant BORDERLESS MINT MTG Magic Double Master VIP Full Extended at the best online prices at eBay! Magic the Gathering, FNM is TM and copyright Wizards of the Coast, Inc, a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc. All rights reserved. Dark Confidant (also affectionately known as " Bob "), released in Ravnica: City of Guilds, is a rare, black creature that allows its controller, at the beginning of his or her upkeep, to effectively draw an additional card at the cost of paying life equal to the card's converted mana cost. My choice is "play a worse version of a deck that wants Bob" or "play a deck that doesn't want Bob at all", and I've chosen the latter. These cards love additional upkeep steps. This is a subreddit dedicated to playing the Commander format of Magic: The Gathering at the highest power level possible. Dark Confidant is so nicknamed after Bob Maher, Jr., its creator. My point is when you go up 1 mana, the expectations the card has to fill drastically increase. For those who gamble, interest may even lead to the occasional, innocent experimentation with sleight-of-hand. I wasn't even familiar with Phyrexian Arena For the same mana Night's Whisper immediately gives you two cards at the cost of two life.